Dear Members,In response to an inquiry from U.S. Senator Grassley (Sept. 2008) Medtronic provided him with a partial list of outside doctors who were
The New York Times reports yet another “paid expert” caught forging drug company research reports. This time
the hammer falls on a former surgeon from Walter Reed Army Hospital, Dr. Timothy Kuklo, an associate professor
of orthopedic surgery and the guilty party in this report.
Dr. Kuklo forged names and appended them to a published journal article which falsified research data
conducted on U.S. soldiers to support exaggerated claims about the effectiveness of Infuse, a bone-
growth product made by Medtronic which is already under investigation for false claims and off-label
marketing. Not surprising, Medtronic was a company with whom Dr. Kuklo had significant undisclosed
financial ties, and this time a separate investigation by the Walter Reed Army Medical Center confirmed
The Walter Reed report, issued in late 2008 was sent to Medtronic's chief executive and to the dean of the
Washington University School of Medicine, where Dr. Kuklo was employed. However, despite the report, as late as
May 13, 2009, a university official declined to say whether it was investigating Dr. Kuklo but confirmed that he
remained on the faculty.
The peer review British publication, the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, that published the fraudulent article later
retracted it, but neither the University nor Medtronic had taken any disciplinary action against Dr. Kuklo.
listed as paid consultants for the Infuse drug. Dr. Kuklo, who has personally conducted about 15 paid presentations for Medtronic about the
product, was interestingly NOT on that list.
In response to an inquiry by the NY Times, a written statement by a Medtronic spokeswoman indicated that Dr. Kuklo was not included
because "some consultants, like Dr. Kuklo, have general agreements that are not specific
to a single therapy or subject matter."
In other words, such doctors are on unspecified retainer with the company, promoting any number of Medtronic products!
Not easily satisfied with Medtronic’s dubious reply Sen. Grassley is now demanding much more detailed information from Medtronic –
including all undisclosed financial arrangements between the company and academic faculty.
The company since has announced its “disengagement from Dr. Kuklo,” a graduate of West Point, the University of Connecticut medical
school and Georgetown Law Center.
Given the serious and potentially criminal charges against Dr. Kuklo – including fraud, forgery, and conducting an unapproved experiment
on soldiers – the University of Washington's failure to take action until a series of articles in The New York Times and more aggressive
investigation headed by Sen. Charles Grassley brought pressure to bear, speaks volumes about a pervasive culture of arrogance in the
drug company “sponsored” academia.
The University of Washington did not see fit to take action until Friday, May 22, when a spokesperson there indicated that Dr. Kuklo would
take a leave of absence from the University.
For the full New York Times article see: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/05/19/business/19surgeon.html
How many of these incidents of falsifying study results, drug company payola and massive criminal and class action settlements need to be
revealed before the FDA is jarred out of its complacent support and lack of real oversight of the pharmaceutical industry?
I say, we already passed that number!
What do you say?
All the best,
Rudi C. Loehwing
World Institute of Natural Health Sciences
See Related articles
The "Business" of Drugs: Former Army Doctor Nailed for
Drug Company Research Fraud
Page created 5/25/09
This file is not intended to be viewed directly using a web browser. To create a viewable file, use the Preview in Browser or Publish to Yahoo! Web Hosting commands from within Yahoo! SiteBuilder.